Creating Japanese Gardens, Philip Cave
This is the book I started with and it was just what I wanted. Gave the history and much of the religious symbolism in the gardening. He comes across as a very strong Japanese patriot. A highbrowed audience intended. High quality instructions. Vague, philosophical ideals. Insists (like many of the others) that you can't simply collage together Japanese elements to make a Japanese garden. You must keep the spirit as well.
The Art of Japanese Gardens, Herb Gustafson
This one, while echoing that you can't simply cobble together a Japanese Garden, gives the tools to do so. Each chapter introduces a certain element, gives an example of the sort of mood it can create or enhance, then proceeds to tell how to apply it. His instructions do not seem to be as thoroughly professional as Cave's, but they are more accessible to the casual amateur. Has useful lists of plants.
Creating a Japanese Garden, Peter Chan
This one was a nice middle ground between the two above. Chan is not nearly so intellectually highbrow, but still keeps relatively high standards. He gave interpretations of Zen gardens, whereas Cave insisted the viewer must find the interpretation for himself.
Japanese Gardens in a Weekend, Robert Ketchell
As the title says, small projects that can be done in one to three weekends. Definitely intended for small scale application. And of course many of the projects can be combined, making a summer long project, if desired.
Create Your Own Japanese Garden, Motomi Oguchi
This one was oddly refreshing. While all the books have given an overview of the historical development, the others were all more or less the same. Oguchi's perspective/approach is unique. Also different, the others gave both examples of famous gardens and some of their own designing; Oguchi only shows his own designs. He has a(n acknowledged) more flamboyant style in the gardens than is advised in the others. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it. I would definitely recommend it as a counterpoint to the others above.
Infinite Spaces, Joe Earle
Coffee table book. Beautiful pictures, short pithy proverblike sayings. It says 'based on the Sakuteiki by Tachibanano Toshitsuna'-- a book I'd definitely seen references too; seems to be the 'bible' of Japanese Gardening. The editor went through and picked out gems and organized them by topic, so I would hardly think of it as a translation, which they certainly don't claim!
Chatboard (0)